Refusing to Learn
The Seoul Times
October 24, 2005
By Domenico Maceri
The letter to the editor of a Southern California newspaper railed against
translation services provided by the government because some immigrants "refuse"
to learn English. I don't know how many immigrants the letter writer has met or
what kind of research he may have done to reach his conclusion.
As an immigrant who is well acquainted with many people from other countries, I
can say categorically that I never met anyone who refused to learn English.
Immigrants know very well the importance of learning the dominant language of
the country. What the letter writer does not know is the challenges immigrants
face in learning English.
The first one is age. Although immigrant kids will learn English like natives,
those who come as adults will learn enough to get by. Some may never learn
English because of low educational background in their own language. It's very
difficult to learn a new language if you don't know your own very well. My
mother, who is 80 years old, came to the U.S. 40 years ago. Barely literate in
her native Italian, she managed to learn but a few words of English.
Speakers of European languages who have a high degree of education in their own
language usually learn English well although they will always retain a foreign
accent. Arnold Schwarzenegger, Arianna Huffington, and Henry Kissinger will
bring their accent to their grave.
Educated immigrants speaking a non-European language will also learn English but
will have a hard time. It might take twice as long for an immigrant from China
to learn English as compared to one from France. While English and Chinese have
little in common, French and English share a number of linguistic features.
These similarities simplify the process of learning English for speakers of
Gender also affects one's learning ability. Immigrant women, who have a tendency
to stay home and care for kids, are less likely to learn than men who go to work
and are forced to have some interaction with Americans.
One challenge that is common to virtually all immigrants in learning English is
time. Immigrants come to the U.S. primarily for economic reasons. Thus they work
long hours. It's difficult to attend night classes after having worked hard the
entire day although many in fact do it.
Anyone who thinks learning a language is easy should talk with Americans who
have lived overseas for many years. Most of them learn little or no foreign
language. Just like it is difficult for Americans to learn other languages, it
is also difficult for immigrants to learn English in part because of the
particular intricacies of the language.
English pronunciation and spelling are particularly difficult. It's no wonder
that spelling is a basic school subject in English-speaking countries while it
does not exist in Italian, Spanish, and other relatively phonetic languages.
Although all immigrants need to learn English, Spanish-speakers have in some
ways less of a need than those from other countries because Spanish is widely
used in the U.S. Radio, TV, and newspapers are not easily available in
Bulgarian, but in Spanish they are. Indeed it's possible to live in the U.S.
with just Spanish. However, it's impossible be very successful in the U.S.
without knowing English and venturing into the English-speaking world. You
cannot become a doctor, a lawyer, or an engineer, without English. English is
the key to success.
Spanish-speaking immigrants want to learn English and get an education because
they understand that without doing so, they will be condemned to a life of
menial work. For proof of this all one has to do is look at the large number of
people attending night classes to learn English and consider the high number of
commercials on Spanish TV peddling tapes and videos promising to teach English
the easy way.
The fact that government provides some services in foreign languages is not a
disincentive to learn English. In fact, the opposite occurs. By having access to
government services, immigrants don't remain isolated in their linguistic and
social ghetto. They interact with Americans and integrate faster in our culture.
And that speeds up their learning English.